Butler Insurance Services

Butler Insurance Services is a family-run independent insurance agency located on Latta Road in the town of Greece, just northwest of Rochester, NY. Led by president J. Clark Butler, the agency serves individuals and businesses throughout New York State. The staff brings over 100 years of combined insurance experience to their work, and the agency holds Trusted Choice membership through the Independent Insurance Agents association — a designation that signals a commitment to offering coverage options from multiple carriers rather than a single company.

As an independent agency, Butler Insurance Services represents several insurance carriers, including Erie Insurance, Dryden Mutual Insurance Company, Allegany Co-op Insurance, Foremost Insurance, and Kemper. Their personal lines include:

• Auto insurance
• Homeowners insurance
• Renters insurance
• Motorcycle insurance
• Boat and marine insurance
• Classic and collector vehicle insurance (through Hagerty)

On the commercial side, the agency writes business owners package (BOP) policies, commercial auto, commercial property, general liability, and workers' compensation coverage. Because they are not tied to a single carrier, they can compare rates and coverage terms across their panel of insurers for each client.

Butler Insurance Services is a Trusted Choice independent agency with deep roots in the Greece community. The agency's independent structure — representing five-plus carriers — allows it to shop policies on behalf of clients rather than selling from a single insurer's product shelf. The firm also serves as a Hagerty-authorized agent for classic and collector car insurance, a niche product line not available through every local agency.

The office sits at 3565 Latta Road in Greece, NY 14612, near the intersection of Latta Road and North Greece Road on Rochester's northwest side. The surrounding area along Latta Road is a mix of small professional offices and residential neighborhoods typical of suburban Greece. Office hours are Monday through Friday, 9:00 AM to 4:30 PM, with the office closed on weekends. Free parking is available on site.