Caraglio's Pizza

Caraglio's Pizza is a neighborhood pizzeria located in Gates at 3869 Lyell Rd, Rochester, NY. Founded by Tony Caraglio — a mechanical engineer who shifted careers to pursue pizza making — the chain opened its first location in Hilton in 2004 and has since grown to eight shops spread across the Rochester area. The Gates location sits at the corner of Lyell Road and Elmgrove Road, in the space formerly occupied by DiRosato's pizza shop.

Caraglio's menu centers on pizza and wings, with a selection of specialty subs and daily slice deals. Pizza toppings range from standard options like pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms to choices such as artichokes, eggplant, and ricotta. The sub menu includes sirloin steak, meatball, chicken finger, buffalo chicken, chicken philly, chicken parm, and eggplant parm varieties. A daily slice special — available until 4 p.m. — offers two slices and a 20 oz. drink for $9, with pepperoni, cheese, buffalo chicken, and country sweet chicken among the options. Ordering is available through their mobile app on iOS and Android, with delivery offered within an approximate 10-minute radius of each location.

Caraglio's is identified with cup-and-char pepperoni — the style where small pepperoni slices curl into little cups and crisp at the edges during baking. Their pizza is screen-baked, producing a thin crust with characteristic browning on the bottom. The chain also runs a rewards program that gives customers a free medium cheese pizza after spending $10, plus a free small one-topping pizza on their birthday each year.

The Gates location occupies the corner of Lyell Road and Elmgrove Road, a busy commercial stretch in the Town of Gates just west of the Rochester city line. Lyell Road serves as one of the main east-west corridors through Gates, lined with local shops and restaurants. The pizzeria is open Sunday through Thursday from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. and Friday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., with both delivery and dine-in service available. Other Caraglio's locations can be found in Fairport, Greece, Hilton, Ontario, Victor, and Webster.