Comparion Insurance Agency

Comparion Insurance Agency operates out of a suite at 1200 Jefferson Road in the Henrietta section of Rochester, NY. The office is a wholly owned subsidiary of Liberty Mutual Group, created in 2021 when Liberty Mutual transitioned its nationwide network of exclusive agents into a new agency model. The Rochester location's team of local agents has served Monroe County and surrounding communities for more than 15 years — predating the Comparion name, which formalized the office's ability to quote policies from multiple carriers rather than Liberty Mutual alone.

The Rochester office provides insurance across several categories:

• Auto insurance
• Homeowners insurance
• Renters insurance
• Small commercial insurance

Agents at this location can pull quotes from Liberty Mutual and more than 50 additional national and regional carriers, allowing side-by-side comparisons within a single appointment. The staff are salaried employees of Comparion rather than independent brokers, which means they work on behalf of the agency rather than earning commissions from a single insurer. Current agents at the Rochester office include Toni Conner, Jeffrey Sachs, and Brian Mulligan.

Comparion's distinguishing feature across all of its offices — including Rochester — is the multi-carrier quoting model backed by Liberty Mutual's infrastructure. Unlike a traditional captive agency tied to one insurer, and unlike a fully independent brokerage, Comparion agents are company employees with access to a curated panel of more than 50 carriers. The Rochester office has maintained a consistent presence on Jefferson Road through the transition from the earlier Liberty Mutual exclusive-agent structure to the current Comparion format.

The office sits in Suite 100-A at 1200 Jefferson Road, within the commercial corridor that runs through Henrietta, one of Rochester's southern suburbs. Jefferson Road is a major east-west route lined with retail centers, hotels, and office buildings, and the Comparion suite is adjacent to a Marriott property near the intersection with John Street. The Henrietta Plaza shopping area and the Marketplace Mall are both a short drive west along Jefferson Road. Office hours are Monday through Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM. Street-level parking is available at the building.