Karen Bortnick Agency - Nationwide Insurance

Karen Bortnick Agency is a Nationwide Insurance office located at 95 Allens Creek Road, Suite 316, in the Town of Brighton, Rochester, NY. Led by Karen Bortnick, the agency serves individuals and businesses across multiple states, including New York, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland, and several others. The office employs approximately 20 staff members and offers consultations in English, Hebrew, and Spanish, making it accessible to a diverse clientele in the greater Rochester area.

The agency provides a broad range of Nationwide insurance and financial products, including:

• Auto, homeowners, renters, and condo insurance
• Business and commercial insurance
• Farm and agriculture coverage
• Powersports insurance
• Life insurance
• Umbrella policies
• Mutual funds and retirement planning services

Clients can obtain quotes and purchase policies over the phone at (585) 271-7683 or schedule an in-person appointment at the Allens Creek Road office. The agency is open Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM and closed on weekends.

The Karen Bortnick Agency is a multi-state Nationwide operation with a team large enough to handle a wide variety of insurance needs under one roof. The combination of personal and commercial lines — from standard auto and home policies to niche categories like farm and powersports coverage — sets the office apart from smaller single-agent shops in the Brighton area. The agency also provides financial planning services through mutual funds and retirement products, giving clients the option to bundle protection and investment needs with a single provider.

The agency's office sits in a professional building at 95 Allens Creek Road in Brighton, near the Twelve Corners area where Monroe Avenue and Allens Creek Road intersect. This part of Brighton is a well-established suburban corridor with a mix of professional offices, local shops, and residential neighborhoods. Twelve Corners Middle School, Brighton High School, and Twelve Corners Memorial Park are all nearby. The office is a short drive from Route 590, providing easy access for clients coming from across Monroe County.