The Sheffield

The Sheffield is a British-inspired neighborhood tavern located at 1776 Monroe Avenue in the Brighton area of Rochester, NY. The pub opened on September 9, 2020, taking over the space formerly occupied by The Otter Lodge near the Twelve Corners intersection. It shares ownership ties with the now-closed Tap & Mallet, another Rochester craft beer destination. The Sheffield serves freshly cooked pub fare alongside a rotating selection of draft beers, wines by the glass, and cocktails.

The dinner menu draws heavily from British pub traditions with dishes like shepherd's pie made with ground lamb and seasonal vegetables, bangers and mash, and beer-battered fish and chips served with triple-cooked thick-cut fries and minted mushy peas. A vegetarian version of the shepherd's pie, called Sheep's Pie, substitutes beluga lentils for the lamb. Indian-influenced options include both chicken and vegetable tikka masala, and a rotating pasty of the week adds variety. The sandwich lineup features items like the English Dip, a coronation chicken sandwich, and a fish sarnie.

The bar maintains 20 rotating draft lines with a focus on craft beer, supplemented by a selection of bottles and cans, wines, and cocktails. A daily happy hour from 4 to 6 p.m. offers all drafts, prosecco, and well drinks at a reduced price. Desserts lean British as well, with sticky toffee pudding, fruit crumble, and a warm chocolate brownie. Beer and food are also available for takeout through online ordering.

The Sheffield has established itself as a British-themed pub in a neighborhood otherwise lacking one, combining traditional dishes like shepherd's pie and fish and chips with a craft beer program built around 20 rotating taps. The kitchen also accommodates dietary preferences with clearly marked vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options throughout the menu.

Situated at 1776 Monroe Avenue in Brighton, The Sheffield sits near the Twelve Corners intersection — a well-known junction where Monroe Avenue, Winton Road, and several other streets converge in one of Rochester's busiest suburban crossroads. The surrounding neighborhood is walkable and residential, with a mix of independent shops and restaurants lining Monroe Avenue. The pub is closed on Mondays, opens at noon on Sundays, and serves weekday dinner starting at 4 p.m., with Friday and Saturday hours beginning at 11:30 a.m.