Tony Pepperoni

Tony Pepperoni is a family-run pizzeria on West Henrietta Road in Henrietta, NY, founded in 2003 by brothers Mark, Michael, and Daniel DiPaola. The three siblings set out to build a neighborhood pizza shop focused on quality ingredients at accessible prices, and the restaurant has remained in continuous operation for over two decades. Tony Pepperoni serves the surrounding Henrietta community as well as students and staff from nearby Rochester Institute of Technology and Monroe Community College.

The menu spans well beyond standard pizza. Guests can build their own pies or choose from roughly 18 specialty pizzas — options like Lasagna Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Spinach Ricotta, and Philly Cheese Steak stand out for their variety. Wings come bone-in, boneless, or breaded with a dozen sauce choices ranging from Honey Garlic Parmesan to Nashville Hot. The sub menu includes both cold options (Italian Assorted, Roast Beef) and hot sandwiches (Buffalo Chicken, Meatball), all served on rolls from DiPaolo Baking Company. Dinner entrees round things out with plates like Chicken Parm and Rigatoni, Haddock Fish Fry, and Red Hook Ale Breaded Jumbo Shrimp. Gluten-free pizza is also available.

Tony Pepperoni runs a sizable catering operation geared toward office lunches, campus events, sports teams, and hotel conferences. Box lunch specials and large-format platters can be ordered for groups of 20 or more.

The DiPaola brothers have emphasized ingredient sourcing since opening — the kitchen uses Stanislaus pizza sauce (never from concentrate), Grande cheese, and fresh-cut meats and vegetables. That ingredient-first approach, paired with a menu broad enough to cover everything from a quick slice to a full fish fry dinner, has helped the pizzeria maintain a steady local following over its 20-plus years in Henrietta. Tony Pepperoni also participates in the Erie Station Village VIP Program, offering residents of that nearby apartment community a standing 10% discount.

Tony Pepperoni sits at 4164 West Henrietta Road, a busy commercial corridor in Henrietta, NY, just minutes from Marketplace Mall, RIT, and MCC. The stretch of West Henrietta Road around the restaurant is lined with retail and dining options, making it an easy stop for students, hotel guests, and local residents alike. Hours are Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., and Friday through Saturday from 11:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. Online ordering is available through the restaurant's website.