Name: Vaegorstein Insurance Agency
Address: 747 W Main St, Rochester, NY, 14611
Telephone: (585) 436-8607

Independent insurance agency offering auto, home, business, life, and health insurance, serving the Rochester area for over 20 years.

Overview

Vaegorstein Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency located at 747 West Main Street in Rochester, NY. Led by president Eric Nicholson, the agency has served the Rochester area for over two decades. As a member of the Independent Insurance Agents association (Big "I"), Vaegorstein operates independently rather than representing a single carrier, giving clients access to coverage options from multiple insurers.

What They Offer

Vaegorstein Insurance Agency provides coverage across five main categories:

Auto insurance
Homeowners insurance
Business insurance
Life insurance
Health insurance

The agency works with several insurance carriers, including Progressive, Foremost, John Hancock, Combined Life, and Prudential. Because Vaegorstein is an independent agency rather than a captive one, staff can compare policies from these different providers to match coverage and pricing to each client's situation. The office is open Monday through Thursday from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. and Friday from 9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.

Known For

Vaegorstein Insurance Agency is a long-standing independent agency on Rochester's west side, with more than 20 years of continuous operation at the same West Main Street address. Its independent status and relationships with multiple national carriers distinguish it from single-company agencies in the area, allowing it to place auto, home, and life policies across different providers from one office.

Location & Neighborhood

The agency sits at 747 West Main Street, along the corridor that connects downtown Rochester to the historic Bulls Head neighborhood. The surrounding stretch of West Main Street is home to a diverse mix of small businesses, restaurants, and shops. The Susan B. Anthony Museum and House on nearby Madison Street is one of the corridor's most prominent landmarks. The West Main Street area is currently undergoing revitalization through the West Main Gateway project, which is investing in façade improvements and streetscape upgrades along this half-mile stretch between Broad Street and Jefferson Avenue.